Sexual Harassment in the Workplace: Legal Remedies and Implementation in Pakistan

Sexual Harassment in the Workplace: Legal Remedies and Implementation in Pakistan

Introduction

Sexual harassment in the workplace is a pervasive issue that affects employees’ productivity, mental well-being, and dignity. To address this concern, Pakistan has enacted laws and established mechanisms to provide justice to victims. The Protection Against Harassment of Women at Workplace Act, 2010 (PAHWWA) is the cornerstone of legal protection against workplace harassment. This essay comprehensively examines the definition, legal remedies, complaint mechanisms, and implementation of this law in Pakistan, with an emphasis on filing complaints before the Ombudsman and the Federal/Provincial Ombudsperson (FOSPA).

Definition and Essential Elements of Sexual Harassment

Sexual harassment is any unwelcome sexual advance, request for sexual favors, or verbal or physical conduct of a sexual nature that creates an intimidating, hostile, or offensive work environment. Essential elements include:

  1. Unwelcome Conduct – The act must be unsolicited and uninvited.
  2. Sexual Nature – It involves sexual advances, requests, or behavior.
  3. Workplace Context – The harassment must occur within a professional setting.
  4. Impact on the Victim – It creates an uncomfortable, hostile, or intimidating environment.

Legal Framework in Pakistan

The Protection Against Harassment of Women at Workplace Act, 2010 is the primary law addressing workplace harassment. It applies to all workplaces, including government offices, private organizations, NGOs, educational institutions, and hospitals. The Act defines sexual harassment, lays down procedures for complaints, and prescribes penalties.

Key Provisions of PAHWWA 2010

  • Section 2(h): Defines sexual harassment.
  • Section 3: Establishes the responsibility of organizations to adopt a Code of Conduct.
  • Section 4-6: Mandates the formation of Inquiry Committees in organizations.
  • Section 8: Provides the right to appeal to the Ombudsman/FOSPA.
  • Section 11: Details penalties, including dismissal and fines.

Complaint Mechanism for Sexual Harassment

A victim of workplace sexual harassment has multiple avenues to seek justice. The process involves internal mechanisms and external remedies.

1. Internal Complaint Mechanism (Within the Organization)

  1. Filing a Complaint: The victim should file a written complaint to the organization’s Inquiry Committee within 30 days of the incident.
  2. Inquiry Committee Investigation:
    • A three-member committee investigates the complaint.
    • The accused is given an opportunity to defend themselves.
    • The inquiry must conclude within 30 days.
  3. Committee’s Decision:
    • If found guilty, the accused may face penalties such as termination, demotion, or fines.
    • If dissatisfied, either party may appeal to the Ombudsman/FOSPA.

2. Filing a Complaint Before the Ombudsman/FOSPA

If the internal inquiry committee fails to deliver justice, the victim can approach the Federal or Provincial Ombudsperson.

Procedure for Filing a Complaint Before the Ombudsman/FOSPA
  1. Prepare a Written Complaint:
    • Details of the harassment incident(s).
    • Names of the accused and witnesses.
    • Any supporting evidence (messages, emails, recordings, etc.).
  2. Submission of Complaint:
    • The complaint can be filed with the Federal Ombudsman for Protection against Harassment (FOSPAH) or the respective Provincial Ombudsman.
  3. Preliminary Assessment:
    • The Ombudsman reviews the complaint to determine its admissibility.
  4. Formal Investigation:
    • The accused is served a show-cause notice.
    • Both parties present evidence and witnesses.
  5. Final Decision:
    • The Ombudsman issues a binding decision with appropriate penalties.
    • The decision can be challenged in the President’s Office or High Court.

Grounds for Filing a Complaint

A complaint can be filed based on:

  1. Sexually Suggestive Comments or Jokes
  2. Unwanted Physical Contact or Advances
  3. Threats or Coercion for Sexual Favors
  4. Sexually Explicit Messages or Emails
  5. Displaying Inappropriate Content in the Workplace
  6. Gender-based Discrimination Creating a Hostile Work Environment

Remedies Available to Victims

Victims of workplace harassment are entitled to multiple legal remedies under PAHWWA 2010.

  1. Monetary Compensation: The accused may be ordered to compensate the victim for emotional distress, loss of employment, or medical expenses.
  2. Workplace Remedies: The victim may be transferred to a different department or granted paid leave during the investigation.
  3. Disciplinary Action Against the Accused: The harasser may face penalties such as termination, demotion, fines, or imprisonment.
  4. Psychological Support and Counseling: Organizations are encouraged to provide mental health support to victims.
  5. Legal Protection Against Retaliation: If the complainant faces retaliation, further action can be taken against the perpetrator.

Applicability of the Act: Does it Cover All Women?

The Protection Against Harassment of Women at Workplace Act, 2010 applies to all female employees, regardless of their employment status or nature of work. It covers:

  1. Government and Private Sector Employees
  2. Contractual, Daily Wagers, and Interns
  3. Employees in Educational Institutions, Hospitals, NGOs, and Factories
  4. Household Workers and Freelancers (With Some Limitations)

The Act is not limited to formal workplaces; it also applies in any environment where work-related interactions occur, including virtual workplaces and remote work settings.

Challenges in Implementation

Despite strong legal provisions, challenges persist in the implementation of harassment laws in Pakistan:

  1. Lack of Awareness – Many employees are unaware of their rights and complaint mechanisms.
  2. Fear of Retaliation – Victims often hesitate to report harassment due to fear of losing their jobs or facing social stigma.
  3. Delays in Legal Proceedings – Prolonged investigations and appeals discourage victims from seeking justice.
  4. Non-compliance by Organizations – Many workplaces fail to establish Inquiry Committees as required by law.
  5. Bias and Influence – Some cases are dismissed due to pressure from influential individuals.

Recommendations for Effective Implementation

To ensure effective enforcement of the PAHWWA 2010, the following steps should be taken:

  1. Strict Monitoring and Compliance Checks: Organizations must be regularly audited to ensure compliance with the law.
  2. Training and Awareness Campaigns: Employees should be educated about their rights and complaint mechanisms.
  3. Strengthening the Role of Ombudsman: The Ombudsman’s office should expedite cases and ensure impartial decision-making.
  4. Legal Support for Victims: Free legal aid and counseling should be made available to victims of harassment.
  5. Publicizing Consequences for Offenders: Employers should strictly enforce penalties to create a deterrent effect.

Conclusion

Sexual harassment in the workplace remains a significant issue in Pakistan, but the Protection Against Harassment of Women at Workplace Act, 2010 provides a robust legal framework for addressing it. The law applies to all women in the workplace and provides multiple remedies, including monetary compensation, disciplinary action, and workplace accommodations. However, awareness, implementation, and legal support mechanisms must be strengthened to ensure that victims receive justice without fear of retaliation. By promoting a culture of zero tolerance for harassment, workplaces can become safer and more inclusive for everyone.

Leave A Comment

All fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required